40 Cute Easter Basket Stuffers that Kids will Love!

This Easter, go easy on the candy. Try one of these cute Easter basket stuffers, instead. Over 40 Easter gift ideas for toddlers, preschoolers, boys, and girls!

It’s almost time to fill those Easter baskets… and, this year, go easy on the candy! With over 40 Easter Basket Stuffers in this list, you are sure to find a few Easter gift ideas for kids. Plus, whether you have a baby, toddler, preschooler – boys, or girls – there is something for all of them.

40+ Easter Basket Stuffers and Easter Gift Ideas

Disclosure: This post was partially sponsored by A Mustard Seed Toys. This page includes affiliate links. All opinions are my own.

For what age group are you shopping? Click to jump to the corresponding category:

Babies and Toddlers
Preschoolers
Boys
Girls

40+ Easter Basket Filler Ideas

Easter Basket Stuffers for Babies & Toddlers

Ya’ll, this stuff is precious. I need a little one just so that I can buy these cute handmade goodies! So, who wants me to sponsor their baby’s Easter basket?

Wooden Bunny Push Toy made with cherry wood by Bannor Toys.
Personalized Easter Bunny Teether made with wood and 100% cotton by Pretty Gift City.
Colorful crocheted Easter Egg Rattles by Green Fox Farms.

Bunny in a Pink Dress crocheted by The Tiny Rabbit Company.
Crocheted Egg and Chick Toy by Unicorn Arts Design.
Felted Bunny made with 100% wool by Propsly.

Knitted “Peep” Bunnies crochet pattern by Bethany’s 5.
Carrot Crinkle Toy with soft plush fabric by Sundays with Munch.
Bunny Teether and Paci Clip made with silicone beads by Row and Me Boutique.

Easter Basket Stuffers for Preschoolers

With a preschooler, I like to select toys that encourage learning and creativity.

My kids are loving their crayon holders from Big Sky Embroidery (also, how darling is that bookmark?). Immediately, my daughter grabbed a page out of her coloring book and got to work.

At this age, they are able to start making Easter crafts (try these watercolor easter eggs or color an Easter Bunny table setting), playing simple Easter games (like Easter themed scavenger hunts) and participating in Easter activities.

Colorful wooden Easter Egg Puzzle by Red Barn Toys.
Bunny Crayon Roll made with felt and perfect for travel by Big Sky Embroidery.
Easter Scavenger Hunt Game that is dry-erase and reusable by Craftivity Designs.

Easy Hold Spring Crayon Set in sets of 3 or 6, by The Crayon Fairy.
Easter Egg Sidewalk Chalk Set by Pastello Rosso.
Easter Pretend Play Tea Set made with felt by Myra’s Kitchen.

Montessori Lacing Toy made with maple wood by Mama Ps Place LLC.
Easter Coloring Stuffed Toys that are washable and reusable by Running Frog.

Bunny Puzzle made with aspen wood by Umbrella Woodworking.
Easter Finger Puppets made with felt by Sweet Felt Toys.

Easter Basket Stuffers for Boys

For boys ages 5-12, I try to tap into their interests with unique Easter gift ideas. My son, now a tween (how did that happen?) loves playing video games, basketball, and exploring the great outdoors. For him, I’d consider a nature adventure kit, a sword and shield set, or a strategy game like number 4, below.

What is your son or grandson into? Let these ideas get you started on your search for the perfect Easter basket stuffer:

Hollow Chocolate Video Game Controller by Chocolates Unlimited.
Easter Scavenger Hunt Game with dry-erase markers by Craftivity Designs.
Wooden Memory Game featuring springtime critters by Essential Montessori.

Wooden Bunny Strategic Stacking Game by White Rabbit Gameworks.
Video Game Controller Tumbler with personalization by Annie Girl Designs.
Dinosaur Egg Bath Bomb with surprise dino toy by Bloom Herbal Blends.

DIY Birdhouse Kit for kids by DJA Woodworks (I love that this kit uses screws instead of nails).
Hatching Eggs Toy with hidden dinosaur toy by Kokimo.
Nature Explorer Kit with a Nature Scavenger Hunt by Craftivity Designs.

Superhero Coloring Characters that are wipeable and reusable by Stitches of Green.
Kids Garden Kit with easy-grow plants by Deckerrd Seeds.

Easter Basket Stuffers for Girls

Lastly, let’s look at Easter gifts for girls in the 5-12 year old range. Little girl gifts are perfectly suited for the sweet pastel color palette of Easter. I mean, how darling is that mini bunny purse and those bunny ear headbands (numbers 7 and 4 below, respectively)?

This year, my seven year old has really gotten into playing with her 18″ dolls (American Girl dolls, Our Generation dolls, etc.) and has a full list of doll accessories on her wish list. For Easter, this darling pink striped doll tent is the perfect choice (make sure to check out A Mustard Seed Toys, she has a great selection of pretend play toys in her shop.)

My daughter would also love to have almost anything on the below list, too… what would your little girl love to find in her Easter basket?

Pink and white stripe tent for 18″ dolls from A Mustard Seed Toys.
Personalized Easter Bunny Water Bottle by Molly D Crafts.
Leaf and Flower Press Kit for springtime crafting by Red Oak Adventures.

Bunny Ear Headband made with gorgeous, high-quality fabrics by Chepstow Stitchery Co.
Easter Scavenger Hunt Game with dry-erase markers by Craftivity Designs.
Fairy Garden Kits with 4 types of seeds by The Gifted Tomato.